38 special vs 9mm short barrel full#

There existed some problems, because many of the early guns didn’t have chambers cut that would allow them to fire without a moon clip holding the base of the cartridges in place. Nevertheless, as far as dedicated ammunition for use in revolvers is concerned, it offers less. 38 Special and is easier to load and eject. This is a potent load! The 9mm is noticeably shorter than the. 38 Special loads (left) display heavy and tough 158-grain Buffalo Bore Outdoorsman bullets made of hard-cast lead. It would be a fair assessment to say that they’ve been adapted to that use only in circumstances for which it’s been necessary for military supply channels or commercial relevance. In general, revolvers have never really been designed to use rimless cartridges. The frame size, barrel length and many other small design elements give a heavy preference to the use of a semi-automatic when looking at small, rimless cartridges such as the 9mm. But, for the most part, revolvers use rimmed cartridges. Of course, there have been many attempts at viability. There are very few revolver designs that are truly optimized for the 9mm cartridge. It offers some unique angles for revolver fans … and some deficiencies as well. The vast majority of people don’t think of the 9x19mm cartridge when talking about revolvers. What image pops into your mind? Cowboys? Gunslingers? Your favorite Western film? Shooting wadcutters in a bull’s-eye match? Hunting game at bowhunting distances?

It's more difficult to make accurate 9mm ammo when compared directly to the.

Most factory loads are optimized for 4-inch barreled pistols, thus lose performance in snubby carry revolvers.

If a case has split in the chamber or a hot handload has flattened and expanded the cartridge case, clean ejection can be compromised.Reliablity can be an issue, because because firing pin depth and primer height is occasionally in question.In all but a few cases, the rimless cartridge requires moon or semi-moon clips to function in a revolver.Why Doesn't the 9mm Revolver Live Up To Expectations: No matter how you slice it, a 9mm revolver is always a compromise. However, they’re beautiful to look at! Smith & Wesson always does a good job in that regard. It’s also easier to hang up on pockets and pouches than a pistol magazine. While magazines are flat and easily carried, the moon clip is bulky and easily bent if not stored safely. Extraction without one is iffy at best-and impossible in some cases, depending on design.

38 special vs 9mm short barrel full#

Extracting with a full moon clip is fast and easy.